New Ontario Regulations for Lepidoptera

Cris Guppy & Aud Fischer cguppy at quesnelbc.com
Sun Aug 29 21:27:07 EDT 1999


I have published the only paper on butterflies of conservation concern in
BC, co-authored with Jon Shepard and Norbert Kondla who have/are doing
various COSEWIC butterfly status reports. I am also presently co-authoring a
book on the butterflies of BC, which will be published in 2000. So I have
put a reasonable amount of thought into butterfly conservation.

There is only one criteria to justify imposing restrictions on the
collecting of butterflies -- collecting must have a reasonable probability
of adversely affecting the population(s) of a species. If that is the case
for the butterflies listed in the regulation, then the Ministry of Natural
Resources should provide reports that document how the conclusions were
reached. At best it is likely that the conclusion will be an "educated
opinion" of one expert, but as long as that expert is credible to the
lepidoptera community as a whole then most people will support restrictions
on collecting.

It is not very difficult or expensive to produce a COSEWIC-type report on
the status of a butterfly. If such reports are not available, it is
perfectly reasonable for the lepidoptera public at large to assume that the
regulations are simply products of the arbitrary personal biases of one or
two well meaning, but essentially ignorant individuals. Or more cynically,
the regulations are an effort to mislead the public into thinking that
government cares about butterfly conservation, so that they can continue to
allow habitat destruction (including widespread pesticide use) to continue
unabated.

So the question I have is "What evidence is there that restrictions on the
collecting of the listed butterflies will have a positive effect on their
conservation?". If there is no such evidence then the regulations should be
deleted. Since habitat destruction is normally the primary issue of concern
in butterfly conservation, it is very unlikely that more than the Karner
Blue (extirpated from Canada) could be adversely adversely affected by
collecting (if it is re-introduced or an unknown population is found --
which will be hard to document given that collecting is forbidden).

-----Original Message-----
From: Donald A. Davis <donald.davis at utoronto.ca>
To: leps-l at lists.yale.edu <leps-l at lists.yale.edu>
Date: August 28, 1999 12:21 PM
Subject: New Ontario Regulations for Lepidoptera


>On January 1/99, the new Fish and Wildlife Conservation Act (1997) was
>proclaimed as law in Ontario. Under this Act, various species of
>invertebrates are now given protection, and activities pertaining to
>these species, such as capture and propagation, are regulated. We are
>just now learning how this Act impacts on lepidopterists and others in
>Ontario
>
>In fairness to those officials with our Ontario Ministry of Natural
>Resources  who must administer this Act, they are very supportive, eager
>to learn about what  invertebrate activities are taking place in
>Ontario, eager to receive recommendations for changes to the regulations
>to the Act.  Under Schedule 11 of the Act, some invertebrates are given
>"Specially Protected" status. As someone who regularly captures, rears
>and tags monarch butterflies, it has been necessary to obtain a Wildlife
>Scientific Collector's Authorization for this falls activities. It would
>seem that those who put Schedule 11 together did not consult with
>provincial entomologists (ie. Toronto Entomologists' Association).
>
>Ministry officials will be attending the next regular meeting of the
>Toronto Entomologists' Association at the Royal Ontario Museum in
>Toronto on Sept. 25th. Your comments and recommendations to this writer
>with regard  to improving this Act would be appreciated.
>
>Don Davis
>Toronto, ON
>-----------------------------------
> Invertebrates and the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Act 1997
>
>The Fish and Wildlife Conservation Act 1997 received Royal Assent in
>December
>1997 and was proclaimed into force January 1,1999.  This new Act
>replaced the
>Game and Fish Act and has implications for a wide group of individuals
>who
>may be involved in activities or species that the Game and Fish Act did
>not
>previously deal with such as butterflies.  Butterflies were totally
>unprotected under the Game and Fish Act.
>
>Butterflies listed as Specially Protected Invertebrates in Schedule 11
>of the
>Fish and Wildlife Conservation Act are as follows: Karner Blue, Monarch,
>West
>Virginia White, Mottled Dusky Wing, Bog Elfin, Black Swallowtail, Giant
>Swallowtail, Old World Swallowtail, Pipevine Swallowtail, Spicebush
>Swallowtail, Tiger Swallowtail, and Zebra Swallowtail.
>
>Section 5 of the FWCA prohibits the hunting or trapping of specially
>protected invertebrates which essentially prohibits the taking of the
>above
>listed butterflies for collecting purposes or any other purpose.
>
>Section 40 prohibits the keeping of live specially protected wildlife
>(includes butterflies) in captivity except under the authority of a
>licence
>and in accordance with the regulations.  Under the regulations a person
>who
>is issued a zoo licence may keep live game wildlife and specially
>protected
>wildlife in captivity and also may buy, sell or propagate them.
>
>Sub-section 40 (2) (b) allows a person to keep a single game reptile,
>game
>amphibian, specially protected mammal, specially protected reptile,
>specially
>protected amphibian or specially protected invertebrate in captivity for
>the
>purposes of personal education.  This would allow an individual to keep
>one
>butterfly of the species found in schedule 11(listed above).
>
>Subsection 40 (2) © allows a person to keep game wildlife or specially
>protected wildlife in captivity for any educational or scientific
>purpose or
>any other purpose with the authorization of the Minister.  This section
>allows for keeping wildlife in captivity for introduction and recovery
>programs and is also used in the case wildlife possessed prior to
>proclamation of the FWCA.  It could also apply to persons possessing
>butterflies for education etc.
>
>Section 45 of the FWCA prohibits the propagation of game wildlife or
>specially protected wildlife except under authority of a licence.  At
>the
>present time, only the holder of a zoo licence is allowed to propagate
>specially protected invertebrates.
>
>Section 46 prohibits the release of game wildlife or specially protected
>
>wildlife that has been kept in captivity without the permission of the
>Minister.
>
>Section 48 prohibits the sale or purchase of game wildlife or specially
>protected wildlife without the authority of a licence.  At the present
>time
>the only persons who can legally purchase and sell specially protected
>invertebrates are the holders of a zoo licence.
>
>Section 54 prohibits the release of wildlife or an invertebrate that has
>been
>imported into Ontario or propagated from stock imported into Ontario
>without
>the approval of the Minister. At the present time, an invertebrate that
>has
>been imported into Ontario by a permit issued by
>CFIA under the Plant Protection Act is exempted from the requirement to
>receive Minister's approval before release.
>
>The FWCA closed a major loop hole in the previous legislation in that
>regulations pertaining to species native to Ontario that came from
>another
>province or country were ruled by an Ontario Court of Appeal decision to
>be
>outside the jurisdiction of the Game and Fish Act.  Clause 1(2)(d) of
>the
>FWCA provides that species referred to in the act include animals,
>invertebrates or fish whether or not it originated in Ontario.
>
>It has become apparent after discussion with many different people over
>the
>past few months that the restrictions and limitations contained in the
>Fish
>and Wildlife Conservation Act and regulations have greatly impacted the
>activities of many  lepidopterists in Ontario.  There is provision
>however to
>provide a regulatory scheme with respect to specially protected
>invertebrates
>(butterflies) which might address the majority of issues.
>
>
>Wildlife Branch
>Ontario Parks
>Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources
>Box 7000, 300 Water St.
>Peterborough, Ont. K9J 8M5
>
>


More information about the Leps-l mailing list