[Fwd: TTR reviewers and peer review part II.]

Jeffrey A. Caldwell ecosys at pacbell.net
Thu Oct 5 00:21:01 EDT 2000

John Shuey wrote:

> I reviewed (signed reviews) a series a really (and I mean really) bad papers
> for several journals.  All were rejected for a variety of good reasons.  These
> papers later showed up with my name included in the acknowledgments, thanking
> me for my review of an earlier draft.  These papers still really suck, but now
> my name has been appended to them, implying that I endorse both the science and
> the conclusions.  A complete embarrassment to me and in my opinion completely
> unethical behavior on the part of the authors.
> I could write this off as an single disturbed senior author, except that it has
> happened again recently with someone else.

I think that in such a case it would be perfectly right for you to not at all
protect the guilty!
I think that in such a case you  have a right, even a duty,  to publicly repudiate
the misuse of your name in the forum in which it was misused. To not do so is to
share in the shame and guilt of it.

More information about the Leps-l mailing list