don't judge a book by its blurb

[Felix Sperling]

Well, by a fine bit of luck I seem to be one of the first to look at 
an actual copy of the Butterflies of Illinois. I can't help but smile 
- this is obviously a very fine butterfly guide and in a thoroughly 
classical style.

Try as I might, I couldn't find a single mention of law enforcement 
officers on the dust jacket or in the contents. On the other hand, 
the authors are professional entomologists, naturalists, and 
photographers of long experience.

As for collecting, the cover states that it is based on "decades of 
collecting throughout the state by the authors". An inside section 
entitled "Collecting and Studying Butterflies" starts by saying that 
"Collecting can be a rewarding activity and is the best way to 
familiarize oneself with these insects. .. We encourage, therefore, 
the responsible collection of butterflies by knowledgeable amateurs 
..."

There are even good county-level distribution maps that make a clear 
distinction between published county records, museum specimen 
records, and the authors' sight records. Making these kinds of 
distinctions can't help but support the importance of collections.

Each species is given a two page spread, with most of one page 
occupied by an equal mix of quite good photos of live specimens and, 
where, necessary, pinned specimens.

I'll leave those who have a better knowledge of Illinois butterflies 
to comment on the details. There is no doubt, though - this book is 
worth getting if you have even a remote interest in Illinois 
butterflies.

...  even if the flyer blurb seems to pander to police states.


Felix Sperling


 
 ------------------------------------------------------------ 

   For subscription and related information about LEPS-L visit:

   http://www.peabody.yale.edu/other/lepsl