Sense and sensibility (in science)

[Morigi, Christine]

Once again, Bruce, you are right on.  I too have begun to hit the delete key
when the posting begins with a ranting of name calling.  Thanks for trying
to bring this list back to a place where theory and statements can be
legitimately questioned without exposing that person to a slew of personal
attacks.  I for one, wish to learn, discuss and challenge without it getting
personal.  

-----Original Message-----
From: Bruce Walsh [mailto:jbwalsh at u.arizona.edu]
Sent: Wednesday, September 29, 1999 10:11 AM
To: Lep List
Subject: Sense and sensibility (in science)


I'm concerned about the increasingly personal nature of some of the
discussions on this group.  Science, like any other human enterprise, has a
strong personal side, but we should take great pains to avoid personal
attacks.

The focus of debates on scientific issues should be on facts and theories
(and the facts that support, or detract from a particular theory).  When
personal attacks occur (i.e., you are obviously xxx or yyy), as a
scientist, you force me to almost completely discount your viewpoint.  This
goes
for individuals on BOTH sides of the current release debate.

Science is not about liking people --- some of the scientists for whom I
have the highest respect are individuals that I personally dislike. 
Likewise, there are scientists that I truly enjoy on a personal level but
whose
quality of science is very poor. 

Just some more random thoughts from an evil, greedy, self-centered,
dishonest,
morally irresponsible, and value-free scientist.

Peace

Bruce

Bruce Walsh
Associate Professor
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology
Biosciences West
University of Arizona
Tucson,  AZ  85721  USA

email:   jbwalsh at u.arizona.edu
Office:  520 621-1915
Fax (Departmental)  520 621 9190

home page:  http://nitro.biosci.arizona.edu

Quantitative Genetics page:  http://nitro.biosci.arizona.edu/zbook/book.ht
ml

Arizona Moths page: http://nitro.biosci.arizona.edu/zeeb/butterflies/mothl
ist.html

Arizona butterflies page: http://nitro.biosci.arizona.edu/zeeb/butterflies
/seazlist.html