gene pool and releases
Neil at nwjones.demon.co.uk
Mon Jun 18 13:28:12 EDT 2001
In article <3B2A9B4E.C6F7FB99 at infinet.com>
minnehan at infinet.com "Randy Minnehan" writes:
> Michael Gochfeld wrote:
> > Actually it's up to those who are commercially invested in
> > butterfly release to demonstrate beyond a shadow of a doubt that there
> > is no disruption to the gene pool nor harm to anyone at any time.
> > Those who oppose it have NO OBLIGATION (in my not very humble view) to
> > demonstrate that it is harmful.
> Excuse me, but exactly how do you prove something that does not exist? I
> asked a trick question earlier when I asked for proof that releases effect
> local populations, because that are NO scientific studies or research that
> have ever shown that butterfly releases have any effect on gene pools or
> local populations in ANY way!
This is a classic error of science. Absence of evidence is not evidence
> It's easy to turn the tables such as you have
> when you have nothing to back you up! Since you want scientific proof that
> no harm is done from releases, I can cite: Dr. Bruce Walsh, associate
> professor, University of Arizona, a well known population specialist has
> proven that the fitness of local butterfly populations is not decreased by
> interbreeding with released individuals.
This is another classic error of science. Argument from authority.
A logical construct is not valid because some expert states it but
because it stands on its own merit.
> Glassberg's writings have been proven time and again to be nothing but
> hot air.
You are wrong. You obviously have a strong belief that you are correct.
Belief in something does not mmean that it is correct.
Show us some scientific proof of ANY harm being done by butterfly
> releases. You cannot.
> Randy Minnehan
Neil Jones- Neil at nwjones.demon.co.uk http://www.nwjones.demon.co.uk/
"At some point I had to stand up and be counted. Who speaks for the
butterflies?" Andrew Lees - The quotation on his memorial at Crymlyn Bog
National Nature Reserve
For subscription and related information about LEPS-L visit:
More information about the Leps-l